By: Marc McMahon

“If the Loving Father Is the One Who Built the Pain, Do We Still Call Him Dad?”

If you realized that your loving Father, who art in Heaven, was the creator of not only you but also your pain, would you still call him God? Would you still drop to your knees and praise him while tears are streaming down your cheeks?

That’s the question that won’t let me sleep lately. Not the fluffy “why does God allow bad things” version we all grew up hearing. No, the harder one: what if He’s not just allowing it? What if He’s the one who scripted every gut-wrenching detail? The car accident that stole your best friend. The diagnosis that turned your body against you. The betrayal that ripped your family apart. What if those weren’t accidents or “mysterious ways,” but deliberate strokes from the same hand that formed the stars?

Look, I’ve tried the Sunday school answers. Free will—sure, people screw up, sin enters, boom, suffering. Soul-making—pain builds character, like lifting weights for your spirit. Greater good we can’t see—God’s got a bigger plan, trust the process. I’ve said them, prayed them, even preached them to myself in the mirror when the nights got long. But when you peel back the layers and stare at the raw truth, those answers start feeling like bandages on a bullet wound.

Because scripture doesn’t hide it. God doesn’t always play the distant observer. In Deuteronomy, He lays out curses for disobedience—famine, disease, enemies crushing you—and says straight up, “I will do this.” In Isaiah, He declares, “I form the light and create darkness, I bring prosperity and create disaster; I, the Lord, do all these things.” Job gets his whole world torched, asks why, and God’s response? Not “sorry, bro, it was the devil” or “you’ll understand later.” It’s “Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation?” Basically, “I’m God, you’re not. Deal with it.”

That’s not allowance. That’s authorship.

So if the loving Father who art in Heaven is the same one who authors the pain—every tear, every scream, every “why me?” whispered into the dark—where does that leave us?

Do we still call Him good? The word “good” starts tasting like ash when you realize the architect might be the one holding the match to your house. Do we still love Him? Love the one who could stop the bleeding with a word but chooses not to? Or worse, chooses the bleeding as part of the design?

I’ve felt the rage bubble up. The kind where you want to scream at the sky, “If You’re real, prove You’re not a monster.” I’ve had nights where prayer felt like talking to the guy who just robbed you blind and then asked for thanks. And yeah, part of me wonders if walking away is the only sane move. If the math doesn’t add up—if an all-powerful, all-knowing being engineers suffering on purpose—maybe rejecting the whole deal is self-respect, not rebellion.

But here’s where it gets messy, and I can’t lie about it: even in the anger, even when the tears are hot, and the questions are sharp, something keeps pulling me back. Not guilt. Not habit. It’s the cross. If God’s the author of pain, He’s also the one who stepped into His own story and let the nails go in. Jesus didn’t just watch suffering—He drank it to the dregs. He cried out the same “Why have You forsaken me?” that echoes in my worst moments. If the Father orchestrated the agony of the Son, then maybe the pain isn’t meaningless cruelty. Maybe it’s the cost of something I can’t fully grasp yet—redemption that required blood, love that refused to stay distant.

Does that make it okay? Hell no, not in the moment. It doesn’t erase the hurt or make the hospital bills disappear or bring back what’s lost. But it shifts the frame just enough to keep breathing. If the God who wounds is the same one who was wounded, maybe the suffering isn’t the end of the story. Maybe it’s the ink He uses to write rescue.

So tonight, if you’re asking the same question I am—if the loving Father is behind the pain, do we still kneel? Maybe the most real response isn’t forced hallelujah. Maybe it’s
Photo by beytlik

Still, I don’t have it all figured out. I’m not here to sell you pat answers or tell you to “just trust more.” If you’re in the thick of it right now, knees weak, faith frayed, praise feels impossible— that’s honest. God can handle the honesty. Job raged, Jesus questioned, David asked, “How long, O Lord?” They’re all in the book.

So tonight, if you’re asking the same question I am—if the loving Father is behind the pain, do we still kneel? Maybe the most real response isn’t forced hallelujah. Maybe it’s showing up anyway. Tears and all. Telling him, “This hurts like hell, and I don’t get it, but I’m still here.” Because if He’s the architect, He’s also the one who knows every crack in the foundation. And if the cross means anything, He’s not afraid to enter the ruins with us.

Would I still call Him God? Yeah, I think so. Not because the pain makes sense, but because the One in the pain does. Would I still praise Him through the tears? Some days, yes, some days it’s just showing up and not cursing Him outright. That’s where I’m at.

Where are you?

About the Author: Marc McMahon. Once, a six-month-old with a gun in his mouth. Now the man who walks back into the darkest basements carrying a light most refuse to admit exists. He turns pain into wisdom, rage into rescue, and terror into testimony, proving that light and shadow can not only coexist but become fiercely productive together. When you read his words, you don’t just read a story; you feel a hand reach through the page, grab yours in the dark, and pull you toward the open door.

A true survivor who writes so the rest of us know we never have to stay trapped again.

Leave a Reply

Quote of the week

"People ask me what I do in the winter when there's no baseball. I'll tell you what I do. I stare out the window and wait for spring."

~ Rogers Hornsby